I wasn’t always a big makeup wearer. While living in Florida my makeup bag consisted only of bronzer, eyeliner and mascara. The rest of it would melt off my face in 0.5 seconds after leaving the house due to the humidity so I kept the routine very simple. Fast forward a few years to an internet bursting with YouTube tutorials and beauty blogs, and well? Now I pretty much own every damn type of product on the market. Here are my favorites…
I’ve come to terms with the fact I will NEVER find a liquid foundation that works for me. And it’s not even a matter of finding the perfect shade. Every makeup artist at Sephora has tried on every possible liquid foundation they carry and every single one of them oxidizes on my skin. I can leave the house wearing a full face of makeup and by the time I make it to work it will have changed to an orangey-pinkish hue on my skin – nothing like what had been on my face an hour before. I’ve tried different coverages, different brands, wearing primer underneath, BB creams, CC creams. You name it, I’ve tried it. Nothing will stay the same color on me. We’ve even experimented with going a shade lighter than my skin so when it darkens up, it would (hypothetically) match. But nope, no dice. My alien skin still turns orange. Sometimes I can get away with a tinted moisturizer and Nars has one with SPF 30 that my skin will play nicely with about 75% of the time. So basically my only option is to spot-correct with concealers. The ones I always reach for are: MAC Select Cover-Up, Clinique’s All About Eyes, and this one from Maybelline with the super long name in Brightener. The last one is my favorite because the pinkish hues really offset the dark circles and make me look awake, despite how many hours of sleep I have (or haven’t) gotten.
Currently my favorite blush is Exposed from Tarte, but Warm Soul from MAC is my summer shade. It has a tiny bit of shimmer in it that I prefer to save for the warmer months. For bronzer/contouring, Benefit’s Hoola was my go-to until recently when I tried this set. Now I’ve switched to Chocolate Soleil from Too Faced. For highlighting I use Hard Candy’s Baked Bronzer (yes, bronzer – it’s more yellow-toned than brown) in Tiki. An eyeshadow palette by Hard Candy was the first thing I ever purchased from Sephora back in the day for about $30. I bought this bronzer in Walmart for $8. Ah, how times change. On a related note, I saw that Kohl’s is now carrying LORAC, Cargo, and The Balm makeup. Not sure how those brands trickled down to them but if you use any, definitely buy them there! They often have crazy sales with 20% or 30% coupons. You could score some pricey makeup for super cheap.
The only powder shadow I’ve worn in the past 3 years is Urban Decay, specifically the Naked Palette. The shadows have great color payoff and are very blendable. The palette is perfect for both day/evening looks. Pretty decent bang for your buck as well, considering UD shadows will run you almost twenty dollars each. The palette has 12 different shades, most of which are now permanent and can be purchased separately. The ones I wear most are Buck, Smog, and Hustle.
For cream shadows, I’ve developed an obsession with MAC’s Pro Longwear Paint Pots. I initially wanted to buy the cult favorite Painterly, but surprise surprise instead of it being the neutral shade everyone loves, it turned pink on me. I went with Layin’ Low which is basically the same thing, a flat nude which can be used as a base or on its own when you’re feeling particularly lazy. From there I added a few more: Bare Study, Rubenesque, and Indianwood. Of those, Indianwood is my go-to. It’s very similar to Smog, which is my go-to in the powder shadow department. The containers look small but they will last you FOREVER. I use Layin’ Low pretty much every single day and have hardly made a dent.
Eyeliner. I have two here: felt tipped liner for top lash line and gel for the water line. I like Maybelline’s Master Precise liner for the top because it’s easy to control. I prefer more of a super-skinny natural line rather than HI LOOK AT ME thick one. This one gets the job done. The water line can be a pain in the ass sometimes because it’s impossible to get eyeliner to stay put in that spot. I wore kohl pencil for years but it required constant touch-ups. Last summer I started using a gel liner, specifically this one from L’Oreal, and it’s been a real game changer. That stuff does NOT budge. I like Bronze for daytime and Blackest Black for nights out.
Mascara is always Clinique High Impact. I’ve strayed a few times (Benefit’s They’re Real & BadGAL Lash, Tarte’s Better than Sex, Urban Decay’s Big Fatty, and almost all of the drugstore ones) and always come back to Clinique. The formula is super dark and doesn’t make your lashes feel crunchy. That sounds weird but if you wear mascara, you know what I mean. Comparable drugstore ones are Revlon Grow Luscious and Maybelline Full ‘n Soft.
I’m pretty low-maintenance when it comes to lip products and always have been. My go-to lip balm is this one by CO Bigelow. I love all things lemon and this stuff glides on super smooth like buttah. Their Rose Salve sits on my nightstand and is great to put on before you go to sleep. You’ll wake up with super soft lips. Both are sold at Bath & Body Works and they usually have the Buy 2, Get 1 Free deal on them. The smell of the Rose Salve was weird to me at first, but I got used to it. An alternative is this one from Sephora – smells minty fresh! For a little color, Nars Dolce Vita is a great shade that works on everyone. Very subtle, “my lips but better” color. For nights out I’ll layer that one and Clinique’s Black Honey.
And that’s it! Obviously the high-end products outweigh the drugstore ones but I try to keep it cheap by buying sample sizes or investing in a full size only when it comes with a free gift. This works well for all of the Clinique items because everything I use also comes in gift/travel size. During the holidays I was able to stock up on minis of my face wash, toner, moisturizer, mascara, lipstick, and eye cream for free when I bought a full-sized face wash and toner.
What are some of your favorite makeup items? Do you lean more towards high-end or drugstore?